1. Introduction

This article is intended to provide information on long-term trends alongside additional data on the characteristics of victims and nature of crime. It may not include the most recent published data, which can be found in the latest quarterly Crime in England and Wales release.

Back to table of contents

2. How is vehicle-related theft defined and measured?

Broadly speaking, a person commits a vehicle-related theft if they steal or attempt to steal a motor vehicle, parts or accessories from a vehicle, or anything from inside a vehicle.

Figures on vehicle-related theft offences are included in the Crime Survey for England and Wales (CSEW) and police recorded crime data, although the information available from each source and their coverage differ.

The CSEW is a household survey and as such, includes offences against private households only but relates to vehicles owned by any member of the household (company cars are included). CSEW offences cover cars, vans, motorbikes, motor-scooters or mopeds used for non-commercial purposes published in three categories:

  • “theft from vehicles”, which refers to both theft of parts and accessories of motor vehicles and to theft of contents

  • “theft of vehicles”, where the vehicle is driven away illegally, whether or not it is recovered

  • “attempted thefts of and from vehicles”, which does not differentiate between attempted thefts of and attempted thefts from vehicles as it is often difficult to ascertain the offender’s intention

If parts or contents are stolen as well as the vehicle being moved, the incident is classified as theft of vehicle.

The police recorded crime category of vehicle offences covers private and commercial vehicles (although does not distinguish between the two) and comprises:

  • “theft or unauthorised taking of a motor vehicle”, where the vehicle is taken without the consent of the owner or other lawful authority; this includes incidents where there is intent to permanently deprive the owner or where intent is not evident, typically including “joyriding” where the car is later recovered

  • “aggravated vehicle taking”, where a vehicle once taken is known to have been driven dangerously, damaged, or caused an accident

  • “theft from a vehicle”, which refers to targeting property in or on the vehicle (this includes attempts)

  • “interfering with a motor vehicle”, which includes crimes where, while damage has been caused to the vehicle as part of an attempt to steal either the vehicle or its contents or take the vehicle without consent, the specific intent of the offender is not obvious1; for example, a car door may be damaged, which shows an attempt was made to open it, but it cannot be determined if the intent was to steal the car or some contents within it.

“Interfering with a motor vehicle” offences as presented in the crime statistics bulletins are equivalent to offences formally referred to as “vehicle interference and tampering”. The CSEW cannot separately identify this category. In comparisons with the CSEW it is included in the attempted vehicle theft category but in some instances could be viewed as criminal damage or even as nuisance, for example, when a car window is smashed with high value items visible on the seat but the items are not stolen.

The taking of vehicles during robberies (often termed car-jacking) is included within the robbery offence group.

The CSEW provides a better measure of national trends in vehicle-related theft. But, police recorded crime data provide a good measure of offences at sub-national level, where the sample size of the CSEW is not large enough to yield estimates with reasonable levels of precision.

Further discussion on the strengths and limitations of the two main sources is available in the “Which source provides the better measure of vehicle-related theft?” section.

Notes for: How is vehicle-related theft defined and measured?

  1. A change in the guidance in April 2014 within the Home Office Counting Rules with respect to interpreting the motive of the offender in the case of interfering with a motor vehicle is likely to have caused the subsequent increases recorded in this offence category. This guidance change was designed to reduce the burden involved in determining which crime category to record the incident within. This is likely to have led to offences that previously might have been recorded as attempted theft of, or from, a vehicle or criminal damage to a vehicle subsequently being recorded as vehicle interference where the motive of the offender was not clear.
Back to table of contents

4. Which groups in society are most likely to be victims of vehicle-related theft?

Police force area recorded crime data show that a large proportion of the police recorded crime category of vehicle offences is concentrated in a few predominantly urban areas. The Metropolitan Police along with Greater Manchester, West Yorkshire and West Midlands police forces consistently account for around 40% of all vehicle offences recorded by the police.

The Crime Survey for England and Wales (CSEW) Appendix tables published alongside our Focus on: Property Crime publication provide information about the household and area characteristics associated with being a victim of vehicle-related theft. These have shown that some demographic groups have been more likely to be victims of vehicle-related theft. Vehicle-owning households:

  • which comprise of an adult(s) and children have been more likely to be victims than households which comprise of an adult(s) and no children

  • where the household reference person1 is either in employment or unemployed have been more likely to be victims than vehicle-owning households where the household reference person is economically inactive (such as a student or retired individual)

  • comprising of private or social renters have been more likely to be victims than owner occupiers

  • with detached housing accommodation have been less likely to be victims than households living in other types of accommodation (semi-detached, terraced or flats and maisonettes)

  • living in urban areas have been more likely to be victims than vehicle-owning households living in rural areas

Notes for: Which groups in society are most likely to be victims of vehicle-related theft?

  1. The household reference person is the member of the household in whose name the accommodation is owned or rented, or is otherwise responsible for the accommodation. Where this responsibility is joint within the household, this is the person with the highest income. If incomes are equal, then this is the oldest person.
Back to table of contents

5. What is known about the nature and circumstances of vehicle-related theft?

The Crime Survey for England and Wales (CSEW) Nature of crime tables provide further information about the circumstances surrounding incidents of vehicle-related theft over the last decade.

A noticeable change during this time period has been the main method of entry used in incidents of vehicle-related theft. Forcing or attempting to force the lock as a method of entering the vehicle has decreased from occurring in around one in three incidents to one in seven incidents (31% in the year ending March 2006 and 14% in the year ending March 2016). Breaking or attempting to break the window has decreased from occurring in almost one-half of incidents to around one in five incidents (48% in the year ending March 2006 and 23% in the year ending March 2016).

Entering the vehicle through an unlocked door has increased from occurring in around one in eight incidents to around one-half of incidents (13% in the year ending March 2006 and 43% in the year ending March 2016), whilst offenders using a key to enter the vehicle has consistently occurred in less than one in ten incidents across the last decade (between 3% and 7% of incidents).

The CSEW “Nature of crime” tables provide additional information regarding the nature and circumstances of vehicle-related theft over the last decade, including:

  • between two-thirds and three-quarters of vehicle-related thefts occurred at home

  • in the majority of years it was more likely that a stolen vehicle was not returned to the owner than returned

  • exterior fittings (such as hub caps, wheel trims or number plates) have typically been the most frequently stolen items in incidents of theft from vehicles, with electrical equipment and valuables also being commonly stolen

  • consistently around two-thirds of vehicle-related thefts occurred during the week (equivalent to around 15% per weekday) and one-third at the weekend (equivalent to around 13% per weekend day)

  • typically just under four-fifths of vehicle-related thefts took place during the evening or night (6pm to 6am) and just over one-fifth took place during the morning or afternoon (6am to 6pm)

Further information about the nature and victims of vehicle-related theft is currently restricted to the CSEW; only limited data are currently available on the circumstances surrounding offences in the main recorded crime collection. It is anticipated that in the future we may be able to provide further information about crime incidents recorded by the police as more detailed data sources become available centrally.

Back to table of contents

6. Which source provides the better measure of vehicle-related theft?

The Crime Survey for England and Wales (CSEW) has collected information on crimes, including vehicle-related theft, experienced by respondents in a consistent manner since the survey first ran in 1981. It captures incidents that are not reported to the police and is not affected by changes in police recording practices, and is therefore a more reliable measure of long-term trends than police recorded crime.

However, the survey will not capture crimes against businesses, so data on commercial vehicle-related theft are not available, or offences committed against people not resident in households (for example, students living in halls of residence). While estimates at the national level (England and Wales) are of good quality, lower-level geography estimates are not robust.

Police recorded crime data have a wider population coverage, including crimes committed against people not resident in households (such as overseas visitors) if reported to and recorded by the police. Lower-level geography data (police force and community safety partnership areas) are also available. Additionally, police recorded vehicle-related theft data have a wider offence coverage, covering business as well as personal vehicles (although it does not distinguish between the two).

The police recorded crime data do not include offences that do not come to the attention of the police or are not recorded by them. According to the CSEW, vehicle-related theft offences tend to be reported to the police by between two-fifths and one-half of victims (although almost all victims of theft of vehicles report the offence to the police).

Also, due to changes in recording practices introduced in 1998 and 2002, it is not possible to directly compare police recorded crime data for any period prior to the year ending March 2003 with subsequent years.

Additionally, there are currently concerns about the quality of crime recording; crimes may not be recorded consistently across police forces and so the true level of recorded crime may be understated. Following an assessment of crime statistics by the UK Statistics Authority, published in January 2014, the statistics based on police recorded crime data have been found not to meet the required standard for designation as National Statistics.

Since the UK Statistics Authority assessment decision, Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary (HMIC) has undertaken an inspection of the integrity of police recorded crime. The Crime-recording: making the victim count report, published by HMIC, found that an estimated 19% of all offences that should have been recorded as a crime were not. The audits looked specifically at violence against the person, sexual offences, robbery, burglary, criminal damage and a residual category of other offences (excluding fraud). It is therefore not possible to provide an under-recording rate for vehicle-related theft as these offences would be classified under other offences.

The renewed focus on the quality of crime recording means that caution is needed when interpreting statistics on police recorded crime. While it is possible that improvements in compliance with the National Crime Recording Standards (NCRS) may have led to increases in the number of crimes recorded by the police, it is not possible to quantify the scale of this, or assess how this effect varied between different police forces. However, the effect of improved compliance with recording standards is thought to have been more pronounced for violent and sexual offences rather than theft offences.

Therefore, on balance, the CSEW provides a better measure of national medium and longer-term trends in vehicle-related theft; although police recorded crime provides a good source of sub-national data for vehicle-related theft offences and can provide a better indication of emerging trends.

Back to table of contents

7. Where can more information on vehicle-related theft be found?

Crime Survey for England and Wales (CSEW)

Crime in England and Wales (quarterly publication) – the preferred source for latest trends

  • Appendix tables A1, A2, A3 and A8 include data on numbers of incidents, incidence rates, prevalence rates and numbers of victims for the complete survey time-series (starting from the year ending December 1981)

  • Quarterly table QT2 includes data on numbers of incidents in the previous three survey years, broken down by quarter of interview

  • Open data tables (Household crime – Incidence and Household crime – Prevalence) include data broken down by demographic information

  • Annual trend and demographic tables D5, D6, D7 and D8 include data on repeat victimisation and incidents reported to the police – note: only published alongside “year ending March” releases

  • Annual supplementary table S14 includes data on victim satisfaction with police handling of vehicle-related theft incidents – note: only published alongside “year ending March” releases

Focus on: Property Crime (annual publication; latest edition published in November 2016) – the preferred source for more detailed analysis, including victim characteristics and details regarding the circumstances of offences

  • commentary in overview chapter on time-series trends and more detailed findings from the latest financial year

  • Appendix table 3 includes data on household demographics of “vehicle-related theft” victims

  • Nature of crime tables 4.1 to 4.10 include data about the circumstances surrounding the vehicle-related theft incidents, including time, location, method of entry and more

Police recorded crime

Crime in England and Wales (quarterly publication)

  • Appendix table A4 includes data on numbers of incidents since the year ending March 2003, following the introduction of the National Crime Recording Standard (NCRS) in April 2002; this is the earliest time period for which the data are directly comparable

  • Quarterly table QT1 includes data on numbers of incidents in the previous 2 years, broken down by quarter

  • Police force area tables P1, P2 and P3 include data on numbers of incidents and rates per 1,000 population in the latest 12-month period and percentage changes with the previous 12-month period, broken down at police force area level

  • Police force area open data include a time-series of numbers of incidents back to the year ending March 2003 by police force area

  • Community safety partnership data include a time-series of numbers of incidents back to the year ending March 2003 by community safety partnership

Focus on: Property Crime (annual publication; latest edition published in November 2016)

  • commentary in overview chapter on time-series trends and more detailed findings from the latest financial year
Back to table of contents

8. What other sources of information on vehicle-related theft are available?

Commercial Victimisation Survey (Home Office)

The Commercial Victimisation Survey (CVS) is a telephone survey in which respondents from a representative sample of business premises in certain sectors in England and Wales are asked about crimes experienced at their premises in the 12 months prior to interview. In 2016, for example, three sectors were surveyed: “wholesale and retail”, “transportation and storage” and “administration and support”.

The CVS is run by the Home Office and data are published on the Home Office’s Crime against businesses statistics web pages.

Data are available on the proportion and number of premises that experienced vehicle-related theft (theft of and from vehicles), as well as the incidence rates and number of incidents of vehicle-related theft in the year prior to interview, by industry sector.

Sentencing data (Ministry of Justice)

The Ministry of Justice (MoJ) publish data on prosecutions and convictions, and sentencing; the latest Criminal Justice Statistics Quarterly (CJSQ) publication is available from the MoJ Criminal justice statistics web pages.

It is not possible to separately identify vehicle-related theft from within “theft offences” in the main overview tables of the CJSQ. However, a separate “Motoring” section is included in these publications, within which prosecutions and convictions, and sentencing data are available for the combined offence of “theft of a motor vehicle or aggravated vehicle taking”. Data are not specifically available for “theft from a vehicle” or “interfering with a motor vehicle”.

MoJ publish data tools on prosecutions and convictions, and sentencing at an offence level breakdown, including a “Motoring tool”; these are available in the most recent CJSQ release.

Scotland

Crime statistics for Scotland are collected and published separately.

Recorded crime statistics for Scotland are not directly comparable with those in England and Wales. The recorded crime statistics for Scotland are collected on the basis of the Scottish Crime Recording Standard (SCRS), introduced in 2004, which like its counterpart in England and Wales, aims to give consistency in crime recording. The main principles of the SCRS are similar to the National Crime Recording Standard (NCRS) for England and Wales with regard to when a crime should be recorded; however, there are differences between the respective counting rules.

Differences in legislation and common law also have to be taken into account when comparing the crime statistics for Scotland with England and Wales.

The Scottish Crime and Justice Survey (SCJS), however, does follow a similar format to the Crime Survey for England and Wales (CSEW), having a shared antecedence in the British Crime Survey (whose sample during some rounds of the survey in the 1980s covered Scotland, south of the Caledonian Canal). So, while there are differences in the crimes or offence classifications to reflect the differing legal systems, the data are broadly comparable.

Police recorded crime and SCJS data are published by the Scottish Government.

Northern Ireland

Crime statistics for Northern Ireland are collected and published separately.

The legal system in Northern Ireland is based on that of England and Wales; the Police Service for Northern Ireland (PSNI) also has the same notifiable offence list for recorded crime as used in England and Wales. In addition, the PSNI has adopted the NCRS and Home Office Counting Rules for recorded crime that applies in England and Wales. Therefore, there is broad comparability between the recorded crime statistics in Northern Ireland and England and Wales.

The Northern Ireland Crime Survey (NICS) also closely mirrors the format and content of the CSEW, using a very similar methodology with continuous interviewing and a face-to-face interview with a nationally representative sample of adults (16 years and over), using a similar set of questions. Therefore, results from the two surveys are broadly comparable.

Police recorded crime data are published by the PSNI and NICS data are published by the Department of Justice (Northern Ireland).

Back to table of contents

9. Other vehicle-related crime

A number of other vehicle-related crime offences are recorded as well as vehicle-related theft, these being “criminal damage to a vehicle” and motoring offences. Both offence types are briefly discussed in this article, with further detail available in upcoming overview article publications.

Data for the offence of “criminal damage to a vehicle” are available in both the Crime Survey for England and Wales (CSEW) and police recorded crime data series. Both data series are published in the quarterly Crime in England and Wales release and annual Focus on: Property Crime release.

Data for the offence group of motoring offences, which covers both notifiable1 and summary offences2, are available in the police recorded crime data series and a number of sources relating to summary offences:

Notifiable offences

Summary offences

Notes for: Other vehicle-related crime

  1. Notifiable offences are “causing death by aggravated vehicle taking”, “causing death or serious injury by dangerous driving”, “causing death by careless driving when under the influence of drink or drugs”, “causing death by careless or inconsiderate driving”, “causing death or serious injury by driving: unlicensed or disqualified or uninsured drivers”, and “dangerous driving”.

  2. Examples of summary offences include “speed limit offences”, “seat belt offences” and “use of handheld mobile phone while driving”.

Back to table of contents

Contact details for this Article

John Flatley
crimestatistics@ons.gov.uk
Telephone: +44 (0)20 7592 8695