The commuting gap: women are more likely than men to leave their job over a long commute
When deciding whether to leave their job, women are more likely than men to accept lower pay in favour of a shorter commute, contributing to the overall gender pay gap.
4 September 2019
Women are more likely than men to leave their job because of a longer commute, new analysis by the Office for National Statistics (ONS) has shown.
The analysis isolates the impact of commute time and pay on the likelihood of someone leaving his or her job, highlighting the different choices made by men and women in the workplace.
As the main providers of childcare and unpaid work, women tend to favour the flexibility offered by a shorter commute. On the other hand, men are more likely to tolerate a longer journey to work in return for higher pay.
This combination contributes to men doing the majority of high-paid jobs, which in turn contributes to the overall gender pay gap.
Women place more emphasis on their commute when deciding whether to leave their job…
Impact of commute time on probability of leaving current job, Great Britain, 2004 to 2018
More likely, women prefer short commutes because they do more childcare and unpaid work.
This is reinforced by the gender commuting gap, which follows exactly the same age-pattern as the gender pay gap. Both open up as people reach their mid to late 20s, implying a link with having children (the average age of a first-time mother was 28.8 years in 2017).
Upon reaching this age, women begin to sacrifice their longer commutes, bringing their average travel time down while average pay plateaus. In the meantime, men maintain their longer commutes while their pay continues to rise.
The commuting gap and the pay gap both widen when people start having children
Median commute time and hourly earnings by sex and single year of age, Great Britain, 2010 to 2018
Annual earnings are calculated by multiplying hourly earnings by a scale factor. The scale factor assumes 37 working hours per week and 28 days of statutory paid leave.
What about regional differences?
The age-pattern of commutes is largely the same regardless of where people live. Men travel for longer than women to get to work, particularly after reaching their late 20s.
Among people aged under 30, men commute for longer than women in all but one of the 20 most populated travel-to-work areas in Great Britain. But the differences are small, no more than two or three minutes.
When we look at over 30s, the difference between men and women widens in all 20 areas, matching the trend seen across the country as a whole.
This trend is most pronounced in Guildford and Aldershot, an area within commuting distance of London. Under 30s living here travel to work for around 20 minutes on average, regardless of sex. While the average commute remains unchanged for women aged over 30, it increases by more than 50% for men.
This divergence could be partly driven by families moving out of London to Guildford and Aldershot, with men more likely than women to continue working in the capital.
The commuting gap does not discriminate by area
Average commute times in the 20 most populated travel-to-work areas, by sex, 2010 to 2018
The analysis used in this article is based on data from our Annual Survey of Hours and Earnings (ASHE). ASHE does not provide information about people’s commuting habits, but it does include postcodes of residence and work for an employee.
We have used these postcodes to estimate commuting time by car and public transport using a trip planner app. We allocate mode of transport based on whichever is fastest, unless the employee lives or works in Central London (in which case we assume they use public transport).
The ONS also publishes self-reported estimates of commuting time in the Labour Force Survey (LFS). These take precedence as our best estimate of commuting time – the calculations used here are for the purposes of this analysis only.